When Mickey and Alba catch Ben lying and try to teach him a lesson, naturally their plan backfires. Meanwhile, Chip devises a spiteful plan to be crowned “Prince” at his school formal, and Jimmy teaches Sabrina how to dance.
After Jimmy purchases an old beat-up car from a police auction, he and Mickey accidentally lock Ben inside. Meanwhile, Alba catches Chip secretly pretending to be Sabrina’s online crush and she encourages him to keep it going.
When Alba goes on vacation, Mickey appoints Sabrina with babysitting duties when she leaves for a night out. When Sabrina decides that a night out of her own is more appealing, she and Mickey end up in jail. Meanwhile, Jimmy meets a new friend.
After Ben wets the bed at a sleepover with fellow classmates, Mickey, Alba and Jimmy go to extreme lengths in order to save his reputation. Meanwhile, when Sabrina loses her fake ID, Chip offers to help get her a replacement in exchange for a night out with her and her friends.
Mickey teaches Chip and his friend how to gamble, and they end up losing a large sum of money. In an attempt to win the money back, Mickey uses Sabrina’s new relationship with the Junior National Women’s Soccer team captain to place a bet on one of their games. Meanwhile, Jimmy becomes overly invested in the soccer team’s success.
Mickey and the gang accompany Alba to church after she admits she may have a substance abuse problem. When she invites her priest over for Sunday football, the Pembertons take a liking to him. Meanwhile, Ben questions his belief in God, forcing Jimmy and Sabrina to guide him.